So here is the finished item (top image). I can't help thinking that the smoke swirls aren't helping the picture though. So below, I have photoshopped out the smoke, just to see how it looks. I'm kind of leaning towards the smokeless version.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/adc56/adc561e55ef8476a0137bc3f62e4d5a57873c6f7" alt=""
This fiddler just seems more solitary and focussed without all the smoke surrounding him. All opinions are very welcome!